Rates are not going up for everyone anymore. That is the part worth understanding.
For several years the Florida story was simple and it was the same for everybody: premiums rose, carriers left, and homeowners had fewer options each renewal. That version is out of date.
Since the litigation reforms, new carriers have entered the state, capacity has improved, and Citizens has been shedding policies to private companies. The result is that renewals no longer move in one direction. Some homeowners are seeing flat or lower numbers. Others are still absorbing increases or losing coverage entirely.
So the useful question is no longer why Florida rates keep rising. It is why your neighbor’s went down and yours did not.
Rate and premium are not the same number
Start here, because it explains a lot of confusing renewals.
A rate is what the carrier charges per unit of coverage. A premium is what you pay. Those can move in opposite directions, and frequently do, because most Florida policies apply an automatic inflation adjustment to the dwelling limit each year.
If construction costs push your dwelling limit up several percent at renewal, your premium rises even if the carrier’s rate held flat or came down. Your coverage went up with it, so the policy is not worse — but the bill is larger, and the renewal notice does not explain any of this.
Before assuming you were hit with an increase, compare the dwelling limit on this year’s declarations page against last year’s. It is the most common reason a premium moved when the rate did not.
Why some homes got relief and others did not
The improvement in the market has not been distributed evenly, and the reasons are specific.
Roof age is still the gate. A home with a newer roof is now competed for by several carriers. A home approaching a carrier’s threshold is still shopping a short list, and short lists do not produce competitive numbers.
Claims on the address matter, not just claims by you. Loss history follows the property. A home with two water claims in recent years is priced accordingly even if they predate your ownership.
Documentation decides who will look. A house with a current wind mitigation form, a clean four-point, and permits for its updates gets quoted by more carriers than the same house with no paperwork. Carriers price uncertainty.
Your carrier’s own position matters. Companies manage how much exposure they hold in a given county or distance-to-coast band. A carrier that is over-concentrated on the Treasure Coast may raise rates or non-renew there while a competitor with room is actively writing the same street.
That last point is why shopping matters more now than it did two years ago. When only a handful of carriers were writing, there was nothing to compare. There is again.
Citizens depopulation, and what a takeout offer means
If you are in Citizens, you have probably received a takeout offer or will.
Citizens is the market of last resort and is designed to shrink. When a private carrier makes an offer within a defined range of your Citizens premium, you are generally required to accept it and move. That is not a marketing pitch, it is how the system works.
Two things are worth knowing. Citizens policyholders are subject to assessments after a severe storm season, which is a cost that does not appear in the premium, so leaving is often financially sensible even at a similar price. And takeout offers are not all alike — the coverage terms, the water damage provisions, and the roof settlement basis can differ substantially between the Citizens policy and the offer replacing it.
Read the offer against your current policy rather than comparing only the two premiums. That comparison is worth an agent’s time.
What to do at renewal instead of just paying it
-
Compare this year’s dwelling limit against last year’s before concluding the rate rose
-
Get a wind mitigation inspection if you have never submitted one, or if you have re-roofed since the last one
-
Check that the carrier has your roof age, construction type, and system updates recorded correctly
-
Ask what your hurricane deductible is in dollars, not as a percentage
-
If you are in Citizens, have any takeout offer read against your current coverage
-
Shop the policy properly rather than accepting the renewal, because the market has more carriers in it than it did
The conversation is different than it was
Atlantis Insurance works with homeowners across the Treasure Coast — Stuart, Palm City, Jensen Beach, Hobe Sound, Port St. Lucie, Fort Pierce, and Vero Beach — along with Jupiter and Palm Beach County, and on Florida’s west coast in Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Port Charlotte, and New Port Richey.
For a few years there was very little an agent could do for a Florida homeowner beyond finding whoever would write the house. That has changed, which makes an actual comparison worth running again. What makes a home attractive to more carriers is covered in our homeowners insurance guide, and the levers that lower a premium without removing coverage are in how much homeowners insurance costs in Florida.
Send us your declarations page and we will tell you whether your renewal reflects the market or just your carrier.
Atlantis Insurance Inc 850 NW Federal Highway, Suite 129 Stuart, FL 34994 561-983-4333
General information only, not legal advice. Market conditions, carrier guidelines, and Florida statutory provisions change over time; confirm current requirements and current market conditions before relying on any of the above.
